Social and Cultural Perspectives and Biases

WORKPLACE DIVERSITY

In a community services organisation, as with any other organisation diversity within the workforce is a key aspect of delivering quality, effective and appropriate service to clients. The key is to integrate these differences into units within the organisation that can act and work toward common goals, maximising services that will meet client needs regardless of the difference.

Clients will all display individual differences and will display differences that relate to their social and cultural perspectives.

What holds a community service organisation and its teams together is a shared field of meaning – a shared set of values, norms and beliefs that surround a shared mission – coherence and direction. This is a workplace culture which is different from the personal culture and personal expectations of individual workers.

Managers, supervisors and team leaders need to actively encourage cooperation and acceptance of diversity, not competitiveness or exclusion. They need to identify and reflect on their own social and cultural perspectives and biases and to encourage workers to do the same.

We all have biases and we need to accept that we have these biases. Self-reflection and introspection can help identify the values held and contribute to the ability to accept that others are entitled to their own values and beliefs.

Community service managers and workers must put their own biases aside, identify their own limitations, increase their social awareness and learn to work inclusively with colleagues, clients and their families and other stakeholders.

They must provide fair and equitable service that does not discriminate or disadvantage any person or group. this is a requirement that is upheld by anti-discrimination and equal opportunity legislation in Australia.

Key areas to which this applies will include, but is not limited to:

-cultures and subcultures within the mainstream society and which might relate to:

  • race, ethnicity, nationality
  • disabilty
  • age – generational differences
  • religious or spiritual beliefs and affiliations
  • gender – including lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (LGBTI)

It is necessary therefore to identify values and beliefs that might influence decisions and to learn to put aside personal opinion and criticism. Managers and workers need to demonstrate objectivity and to be non-judgemental with regard to client needs, preferences and expectations.

They need to work at developing insights into their attitudes to reduce the risk of making work decisions based on pre-existing perceptions and to avoid causing offence or being dismissive of employee differences.

CULTURE

The attitudes and beliefs of people relate directly to the culture in which they were raised or to the culture they have chosen to accept as their own.

Within every society there will be a range of cultures – as they relate to upbringing, beliefs, expectations, morals and ethics, behavioural mores, religious or spiritual focus etc. A person’s culture can have an enormous impact on their behaviour, insights and interactions with others.

A person’s understanding of their own and other’s cultural identity develops from birth and is shaped by the values and attitudes prevalent at home and in the surrounding community.

When considering their own social and cultural perspectives, biases and limitations managers and workers should be aware of the need to understand how their own cultural identity will impact on their work and their relationships with work colleagues, clients, clients’ families and other stakeholders.

Although it is obvious that culture influences human interactions culture must be viewed as dynamic rather than static. In other words, culture and the behavioural expectations of its members change over time.

Cultural identity can be strongly influenced by the belief system fo the country, region, spirituality or family to which a person is attached. Belief systems are influenced by the history of the people and traditions that have developed over time but they too are not static.

It must also be recognised that:

  • members of a particular cuture or ethnicity will not always think and act in ways that are consistent with their cultural background
  • within all large cultural groups there are a range of subgroup which have different identities
  • it is not possible to make accurate predictions of people’s behaviours, beliefs and values by identifying them as belonging to a certain ethnic, religious or lifestyle demographic

Stereotyping is the process of judging individuals on the basis of what you consider to be their cultural affiliation. Gender, sexual and racial stereotypes are often denigration and unkind. They are also often prejudicial, untrue and do not take into account individual differences. Stereotypes can be positive or negative, but are usually an exaggerated idea of group characteristics that are transferred to each of the individuals in the group.

Stereotyping might include making broad statements about people, such as:

  • vegetarians are healthy
  • African-Americans are good athletes
  • Asian people are good at mathematics
  • Older people are not interested in the same things as younger people

Stereotyping can lead to discrimination, as it removes a person’s individuality and over simplifies qualities that might have a passing acquaintance with the truth. It places people into particular groups and attributes characteristics to them that might not necessarily be attributable to them as individuals.

Most stereotypes are based on misinformation and prejudice. They should. not influence your working relationships.

When dealing with work mates, clients, customers and colleagues, be sensitive to each person’s sense of self esteem. Avoid derogatory labelling which can demean and dehumanise people.

When reflecting on their own social and cultural perspectives and biases managers and workers should examine the stereotypes with which they are familiar and make a conscious effort to relate to people on the basis of individuality, not on the basis of perceived group affiliations and characteristics. These insights can be used to support their understanding of others, to improve their self and social awareness and to increase their ability to work in a diverse workforce and support inclusivity.

BELIEFS

Beliefs are an important part of a person’s identity, and could relate to spiritual, cultural or moral principles and ideals. Beliefs reflect who an individual is and how they live their life. Again, different people will hold different beliefs and a person’s beliefs cannot be identified on the basis of cultural affiliation but can be identified on the basis of behaviour.

Socialising agents, such as peer groups, media, parents/family and teachers, influence the development of beliefs. Beliefs can, for some people, become more complex and fluid over time as they develop allegiances to different groups and subgroups within the broader society. Belief systems and ways of life adapt under other cultural influences including mass media and popular culture to create new identities.

Current forms of social communication processes, particularly mainstream media, advertising, television and film, along with family, friends, teachers, political agendas, religion, society’s rules, personal perceptions, perspectives, interpretations and assumptions (and those of others) all play a part in creating identity. Sometimes these external factors are more of a subconscious influence in the creation of a cultural identity. In a culturally diverse society like Australia, individuals can have multiple identities as they identify and interact with several different subcultures.

IMPACT/CHANGES

In a democratic society we elect our representatives. This implies that the majority of people hold similar views; however, it also acknolwedges the fact that individuals will have different political views and expectations.

Each elected government will make changes that impact on work and these changes will be based on their perception of what society needs and of what will benefit the people living in Australia. Social attitudes change constnatly.

New scientific, medical and health research contributes to changes in behaviour and in belief structures.

For example, issues surrounding these things are constantly changing:

  • sustainability issues
  • climate change
  • healthy eating
  • exercise
  • prevention of sun exposure cancers
  • realisation that diversity is important and necessary

SOCIAL AND CULTURAL PERSPECTIVES and BIASES

As research provides us with more and more knowledge our attitudes, behaviours and beliefs shift. In particular, the concepts of tolerance and inclusivity are more often articulated and more likely to be accepted than previously.

Community services organisations need to be aware of this and might, for instance, make health and fitness programs available for a range of clients of different ages and with different abilities, where previously the assumption might have been made that only younger people will participate in fitness programs.

The economic climate will have a strong influence on the type of service required by clients, on their ability to access the services and on client needs. For example, in times of economic stress community service organisations will be faced by a greater number of clients needing financial advice/financial assistance, help with job search, or treatment for depression/anxiety.

Cultural differences impact on work and life in so far as the increasing number of migrant and refugee people in Australia contributes, and has done since the 1940s and 50s, to the richness of mainstream Australian culture.

The strong cultures of our Indigenous populations and those of our migrant populations have contributed to the diverse range of arts and crafts, food styles and food varieties, literature, spiritual affiliations, music, languages etc that now make up part of what we perceive as of our normal culture. This diversity makes positive contributions to the work, social and economic lives of everybody.

Not only do we need to identify and reflect on our own social and cultural perspectives and biases, we need to learn to understand others and value the differences they bring to our lives and our society. We need to reflect on our own limitations with regard to self and social awareness. This will help us become more accommodating of difference.

USING REFLECTION TO WORK INCLUSIVELY

Reflection and introspection can provide insights into a person’s own identity, self-image, limitations and ability to work inclusively. Reflection can be used to help a person learn about their own motivations. It is a method of assessing themselves and their own biases; the ways in which they work, react, make decisions; and, in this context, respond to diversity.

The theory of unconscious bias supports the concept that individuals can have biases that influence their decision-making by that they are not aware of the bias. Day-to-day decisions are actually informed by stereotypes that people are not consciously aware of holding.

Reflection can help people identify behaviours that result from this unconscious bias and help them re-order their thinking processes to eliminate unconscious acceptance of stereotypes or, at the least to prevent stereotypical reactions.

When attempting to identify reasons for their own behaviours and the potential outcomes of removing bias they might consider issues such as:

  • respect
  • courtesy
  • sharing
  • fear of difference
  • self-fulfilment
  • self-improvement
  • similarities between themselves and people from a range of cultures, looking for similarities, commonalities and meeting points, rather than differences
  • questions they could ask work colleagues or clients to help them learn about different cultures
  • conscious and unconscious bias
  • their ability to support inclusivity
  • strategies for increasing understanding of others
  • ways in which they can improve their self and social awareness

They might reflect on their own strengths, weaknesses, skills, problem-solving abilities and achievements. Self reflection is something that people generally do but often it is not a conscious process. Reflecting helps people develop their skills, review their effectiveness and make changes to their beahviours where necessary.

It is about looking at things that have been done and determining ways in which they can be done better next time – questioning, in a positive way, what you do, why you do it and whether there is a better or more efficient way of doing it in the future.

AWARENESS OF OWN LIMITATIONS IN SELF AND SOCIAL AWARENESS

Reflection can help a person identify their own biases and increase their awareness of their own limitations and social awareness. The process of identifying these thins and increasing self-awareness can help a person follow strategies that enable them to understand others better, be more tolerant, improve their social awareness and more actively and efficiently support inclusivity.

IMPROVING OWN SELF AND SOCIAL AWARENESS

When acting on ways to improve their self and social awareness people should consider that:

  • difference is good
  • communication will be effective if they make allowance for, and accept that difference is important
  • accommodating diversity includes constantly beign aware of politicially correct (non-discriminatory and non-harassing) behaviour and language
  • people work best when they believe they are valued – this includes managers, supervisors, team leaders and workers
  • all stakeholders will feel most valued when they perceive that differences are being taken into account and that effective stratgeies to support effective communication are developed
  • the ability to learn from people perceived as different is the key to empowerment and the building of effective, mutually interdependent relationships

To modify behaviour and attitudes people have to be personally and socially aware. What this means is that they need to understand themselves but they also need to learn to understand others.

This involves developing:

  • empathy (understanding another person’s emotions, needs and concerns) – being able to see an issue, problem or concern from another person’s point of view (this does not necessarily imply agreement, it simply means being thoughtful, considerate and understanding their fear, anger, excitement etc)
  • a degree of organisational awareness – undersatnding the politics within the organisation but also understanding the culture and the individual people within the organisation
  • a high-level service ethic – the service ethic that ensures that he needs of clients, regardless of diversity, are acknowledged and met
  • the ability to work effectively, efficiently and cooperatively with people at all levels in the organisation and with people from a wide range of backgrounds

To build personal and social awareness people need to:

  • ensure they have (or develop good listening skills – active listening
  • ask questions
  • use effective and appropriate communication skills
  • be aware and perceptive with regard to the emotions of others
  • think about their own feelings
  • know their own strengths and limitations
  • develop: – self awareness – learn to recognise and manage their own emotions – take time to think about what they will do or say before they do it.
    • – self regulation – choose appropriate responses for particular situations, control impulses, be flexible, trustworthy, control negative reactions and take initiative where necessary.
  • develop emotional intelligence – the ability to manage responses
  • manage their own stress levels
  • ask others for feedback, opinions and ideas
  • work on developing non-negative assumptions about self and about others
  • ensure that they have a healthy work-life balance
  • be responsive to change

They need to recognise the areas that should be developed and take action. This could involve participation in emotional intelligence training, or in a course on communication or other self-awareness self-development training courses or programs.

Social awareness refers to the ability to understand how you react in different social situations.

Understanding enables people to modify interactions to achieve the best results.

This is part of the understanding of emotional intelligence and to increase or improve emotional intelligence people can:

  1. learn to identify which types of situations make you uncomfortable, and then alter your behaviour to make the best of your circumstances.
  2. Learn to become aware of the behaviours in other people that may cause you to respond negatively. As you are unlikely to be able to change the other person, you must be able to modify your own behaviour to turn the situation into a positive experience.
  3. Take ownership for your behaviour and be willing to apologise for lapses or errors in judgement or insensitive actions.
  4. Ask others for their honest feedback about the way you interact with them. Accept the negative fedback along with the positive (without getting defensive) and make changes accordingly.
  5. Be aware of your body language. Non-verbal communication is more important than what you have to say. Positive body language will benefit your interactions with ohteter people.
  6. Learn to listen with genuine interest. Fight the urge to respond immediately and really listen to what the other person is trying to say.
  7. Accept that improving your social skills is not an overnight process. Trying to improve or change too many things at once will be counter-productive as you will feel so uncomfortable that you may suffer an emotional hijacking.